Guide
Wooden wick candles: why they go out, sizing, pros and cons
A wooden wick that keeps going out is usually trimmed too long or too narrow for the jar. Wood draws melted wax up more slowly than cotton, so the wick has to sit low: suppliers recommend about 1/8 to 3/16 inch (3 to 5 mm) above the wax, trimmed before every lighting. If it still goes out, the wick may be too narrow for the jar's diameter, the fragrance load may be too high, or too many additives may be clogging it. Wood wicks are sized by the jar's width, and they work in container candles only, not pillars.
Why a wooden wick keeps going out
| Cause | What to do |
|---|---|
| Wick trimmed too long | Trim to about 1/8 to 3/16 inch before every lighting. Makesy says a longer wood wick can't pull the wax up, so the flame dims or goes out. |
| Ash built up on the tip | Break the charred tip off once the wick is cool, or cut it with a wick trimmer. Makesy notes heavy ash shrinks the flame. |
| Wick too narrow for the jar | Move up a size. Windy Point Soap lists a wick that isn't wide enough for the diameter as a main cause, along with tunneling. |
| Wick too thin to draw enough wax | Use a thicker wick, or one with a booster strip layered on. |
| Fragrance load too high | Lower the fragrance percentage. Supplies for Candles names this as the usual reason a wood wick goes out mid-burn. |
| Too many additives or colour | Additives can clog the wick's capillary flow. Cut back, or switch to a thicker wick. |
| Knots or flaws in the wood | Wood is a natural material. Candle Shack notes knots can affect the capillary action, so the odd wick will go out even when everything else is right. |
Wood wick size chart by jar diameter
Measure the jar across the inside at its widest point. These charts are starting points: wax, fragrance and colour all change how a wick burns, so test before you sell.
| Jar diameter | Candles and Supplies size | Supplies for Candles size (width) |
|---|---|---|
| 2 in51 mm | XS | S (9 mm) |
| 2.5–3 in63–76 mm | S | M (12 mm) |
| 3–3.5 in76–88 mm | M | L (16 mm) |
| 3.5–4 in88–101 mm | L | XL (19 mm) |
| 5 in127 mm | XL | — |
Supplies for Candles gives its sizes in millimetres (S 50–63 mm, M 63–76 mm, L 76–88 mm, XL 88–101 mm). Candles and Supplies gives single diameters (2, 3, 3.5, 4 and 5 inches) and says you may need to go a size or two up or down depending on the wax. Each brand sizes differently, so use the chart from the brand you buy. If the melt pool won't reach the edge, go up a size or double up two wicks. If the flame is too tall, Supplies for Candles suggests trimming a thin strip off one edge.
For cotton wicks and the burn test itself, see the candle wick size guide.
Wooden vs cotton wicks
| Wooden wick | Cotton wick | |
|---|---|---|
| Trim length | About 1/8–3/16 in (3–5 mm) | About 1/4 in |
| Flame | Wide and low, spreads along the wick | Tall and narrow |
| Sound | Soft crackle, especially with a booster strip | Silent |
| Tip | A little ash, no mushrooming | Can form a carbon "mushroom" |
| Candle types | Container candles only | Containers, pillars and votives |
| Sizes | A handful of widths per brand | Many series and sizes |
| Consistency | Natural wood varies, so the odd wick may go out | More consistent from wick to wick |
Candles and Supplies says the wide horizontal flame builds a melt pool faster. It adds that fragrance oils can make the crackle louder or quieter. Makesy notes that wood wicks don't mushroom and leave only a slight ash tip.
Which waxes work with wood wicks
- Soy, coconut and blends: the usual choice. Northwood says its wood wicks work well in soy and paraffin blends.
- Straight paraffin or palm wax: Candles and Supplies does not recommend wood wicks for these.
- Beeswax as a helper: Supplies for Candles suggests a small amount of beeswax can help the wick draw wax by raising the blend's viscosity.
- Pillars: not suitable. Wood wicks are for container candles only.
Keep the fragrance at a moderate load to start, and work out the weight with the fragrance oil calculator.
Making a wooden wick candle: the key steps
- Slide the wick into its metal clip (sustainer) and fix it to the centre of the jar. Wood is stiff, so it stands straight without a centring tool.
- Pour the wax and let it cure as usual. See how long to cure candles.
- Trim the wick to about 1/8 to 3/16 inch before the first lighting, and again before every burn.
- Burn test: let the candle burn long enough to form a full melt pool, and check that the flame stays lit and the pool reaches the edge. Note the result on the candle recipe sheet.
Wooden wicks are covered by patents. Supplies for Candles says candles sold with its wicks must carry a patent notice linking to the patent holder's page. Check the terms from your own supplier before selling.
Frequently asked questions
Why does my wooden wick candle keep going out?
Most often the wick is too long. Trim it to about 1/8 to 3/16 inch so the wax can reach the flame. Other causes are a wick too narrow for the jar, too much fragrance or additives, ash on the tip, or a knot in the wood.
How short should you trim a wooden wick?
Shorter than cotton. Makesy recommends 1/8 to 3/16 inch and no longer, and Supplies for Candles says 5 mm or less. Candles and Supplies gives 1/4 inch, so if your wick keeps going out, go shorter. Trim before every lighting.
What size wooden wick do I need?
It depends on the jar's inside diameter and the brand, because each brand sizes differently. A 4 inch (101 mm) jar is a large in the Candles and Supplies chart and an extra-large in the Supplies for Candles chart. Use your supplier's chart, then burn test.
Can you use wooden wicks in pillar candles?
No. Suppliers make them for container candles only.
Are wooden wicks better than cotton?
Neither is better in general. Wood gives a wide flame, a soft crackle and no mushrooming, but there are fewer sizes and natural wood is less consistent. Cotton is easier to size and works in any candle type.
Get the amounts right first. The wax & fragrance calculator estimates how much wax and fragrance oil your jar needs.