Guide
Candle flame too high, flickering or smoking? Causes and fixes
Most flame problems come down to three things: a wick that's too long, a wick that's too big for the candle, or moving air. First blow the candle out, let it cool, trim the wick to ¼ inch, and relight it away from fans, vents and open windows. A healthy container candle flame is steady and about ½ to 1 inch tall. If the flame still runs high, smokes or mushrooms after trimming, and you made the candle, the wick is probably a size too large, or the fragrance load is too high for the wax.
Diagnose the flame
| What you see | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Flame taller than about 1 inch | Wick not trimmed, or wick too large | Trim to ¼ inch; if it grows back fast, size the wick down |
| Flame flickers or dances | Drafts, or a long wick | Move away from air flow; trim the wick |
| Black smoke while burning | Incomplete burning: long or oversized wick, drafts, or too much fragrance | Trim, move the candle, then size down or lower the load |
| Black soot ring on the jar | Repeated smoking or flickering | Same as above; wipe the jar when cool |
| Black blob on the wick tip ("mushrooming") | Carbon build-up from long burns or an oversized wick | Snip it off before relighting; size down if it's constant |
| Tiny flame that struggles | Wick trimmed too short or too small | Pour off a little wax or size the wick up |
Flame too high
A long wick draws up more melted wax than the flame can burn cleanly, so the flame grows. Harlem Candle Co. calls this the most common cause and suggests ½ to 1 inch as normal for most container candles, up to about 2 inches for large pillars. The candle safety standard ASTM F2417 sets a maximum flame height of 3 inches for most indoor candles.
- Trim the wick. Cut it to ¼ inch before every burn. On long burns, blow it out, let it cool and trim again.
- Keep the melt pool clean. The National Candle Association warns that wick trimmings, matches or other debris in the wax can act as an extra wick and make the flame flare.
- If it keeps growing: the wick is too large for the jar, or the candle is overloaded with fragrance. That's a candle-making fix (below).
Flickering
The National Candle Association explains that a flickering flame has been disturbed, and that lets soot escape. Usually the air is moving: a fan, an air vent, an open window or door, or even people walking past. Candles placed close together can also create their own draft, so it recommends keeping them at least 3 inches apart. If the air is still and the flame flickers anyway, trim the wick.
Smoke and soot
Black smoke is unburned carbon from incomplete burning. House of Scent lists the usual causes in order: a wick that's too long, a wick that's too big, a fragrance load above what the wax can hold, drafts, and burning for too long at a time. A brief puff when you blow a candle out is normal. Steady dark smoke while it burns is not.
- Blow it out, let it cool and trim the wick to ¼ inch.
- Move it away from drafts.
- Burn for no more than 4 hours at a time, then let it cool, trim and relight. The National Candle Association recommends the same.
- If it still smokes and it's your own candle, test a smaller wick or a fragrance load 1% lower.
Mushrooming wicks
A mushroom is a black, glowing blob of carbon that builds up on the tip of a wick. It's common on cotton-core wicks during long burns and when the wick is oversized. It makes the flame bigger and smokier and can drop hot debris into the wax. Snip it off when the candle is cool, before relighting. If a candle mushrooms heavily within an hour or two, the wick is too large for that wax and fragrance.
For candle makers: fixing the cause
If customers trim the wick and the flame still misbehaves, the fix is in the recipe:
- Size the wick down. House of Scent suggests testing one size smaller and comparing flame height, melt pool and soot. A wick that works with one fragrance may run hot with another, so test each scent.
- Lower the fragrance load. Oil the wax can't hold burns less cleanly. Drop 1% and retest. See typical fragrance loads by wax.
- Check dyes and additives. Heavy dye loads can change how a wick burns, so retest when you change the color.
- Burn-test properly. Burn test candles in 3 to 4 hour cycles all the way down the jar, and note flame height each time. See how to choose the right wick size.
Over-wicked candles also tend to get very hot jars and deep melt pools. Under-wicked candles tunnel and have weak flames, so a wick change can swing a candle from one problem to the other. Change one size at a time.
Safe burning, in short
- Trim the wick to ¼ inch before every burn.
- Burn no more than 4 hours at a time.
- Keep candles away from drafts and at least 3 inches apart.
- Keep the melt pool free of debris.
- Never leave a burning candle unattended.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my candle flame so high?
Usually the wick is too long. Blow the candle out, let it cool, trim the wick to ¼ inch and relight. If the flame grows tall again within an hour, the wick is too large for the candle or the fragrance load is too high.
How tall should a candle flame be?
For most container candles, about ½ to 1 inch, steady and teardrop-shaped. Large pillars can run up to about 2 inches. The ASTM F2417 safety standard caps flame height at 3 inches for most indoor candles.
Why is my candle flickering?
Moving air is the usual cause: fans, vents, open windows or people walking past. Move the candle to a still spot and keep candles at least 3 inches apart. If it still flickers, trim the wick.
Why is my candle smoking black smoke?
Black smoke means incomplete burning, most often from a wick that's too long or too big, drafts, too much fragrance oil, or burning for too long. Trim the wick, move the candle out of drafts and burn for no more than 4 hours at a time.
What does it mean when a candle wick mushrooms?
Carbon has built up on the wick tip, usually from a long burn or an oversized wick. Snip the blob off when the candle is cool. If it happens quickly every time, the wick is too large for that candle.
Choosing a new wick? Start with the wick size guide and burn-test one size up and down.